Avior Aqua

Sludge bulking: causes, SVI and how to fix it

When the sludge blanket in a secondary clarifier keeps rising and solids start to leave with the treated water, bulking is the usual suspect. It affects activated sludge, extended aeration and SBR plants, in ETPs and STPs alike. This page explains how to confirm it, how to tell it from problems that look similar, what causes it and how to fix it, starting with the checks that cost least.

What is sludge bulking?

Sludge bulking is activated sludge that settles and compacts poorly in the secondary clarifier, so the blanket rises and solids leave with the treated water. It usually comes from filamentous bacteria holding the flocs apart, less often from slimy, non-filamentous growth. A sludge volume index above about 150 mL/g is the common warning sign.

How is SVI calculated?

SVI is the volume one gram of sludge takes up after settling. Fill a one-litre cylinder with mixed liquor, read the settled volume after 30 minutes in mL/L, and divide by the MLSS in g/L. Below about 100 mL/g sludge generally settles well; above about 150 mL/g, treat it as bulking.

Example. Settled volume 600 mL/L and MLSS 3,000 mg/L, which is 3 g/L, give an SVI of 600 ÷ 3 = 200 mL/g: a bulking sludge.

Log SVI daily, next to dissolved oxygen and the blanket depth in the clarifier. A steady climb over a week tells you more than any single reading, and it gives you time to act before solids reach the outlet.

Bulking or something else?

Check before you treat. A high SVI with filaments under the microscope is filamentous bulking; a high SVI with slimy sludge and few filaments is the non-filamentous kind. Floating clumps with gas bubbles, or a turbid outlet with a low SVI, are different problems with different fixes.

Sludge bulking and look-alike problems
What you seeLikely problemClue
Blanket rises, clear water above it, high SVIFilamentous bulkingFilaments reaching out of the flocs under a microscope
High SVI, slimy or jelly-like sludge, few filamentsNon-filamentous (viscous) bulkingOften a nutrient shortage
Clumps of sludge float in the clarifier with small gas bubblesRising sludge from denitrificationNot bulking; SVI may be normal
Turbid outlet, small dense flocs, low SVIPin flocThe opposite of bulking
Thick, stable brown foam on the aeration tankFoaming filamentsRelated; fats encourage it

What causes filamentous bulking?

Conditions that suit filaments better than floc-forming bacteria. The usual triggers are low dissolved oxygen, a low food-to-microorganism (F/M) ratio, nutrient shortage, septic influent carrying sulphide or organic acids, fats and oil, and low pH. Different filaments follow different triggers, so a microscope check points to the cause.

  • Low oxygen. Activated sludge and MBBR plants commonly run at about 2 mg/L in the aeration tank. A probe near a diffuser can read well while corners and peak hours run short.
  • Low F/M. An underloaded plant carrying too much biomass favours some filaments. Check MLSS against the load the plant actually receives.
  • Nutrient shortage. A BOD:N:P ratio of about 100:5:1 is the usual guide; some industrial effluents are short of nitrogen or phosphorus and need dosing.
  • Septic influent. An equalisation tank that turns septic sends sulphide and organic acids into the aeration tank; the rotten-egg smell is the sign.
  • Fats and oil. Fats encourage foaming and filamentous growth, which is why oil traps matter to the biology downstream.

How to fix sludge bulking

First, protect the outlet.

  1. Watch the clarifier blanket and adjust return sludge to keep it down.
  2. A coagulant or polymer aid at the clarifier can hold solids back for a while.
  3. Chlorine or hydrogen peroxide dosed carefully into the return sludge knocks back filaments, but it does not remove the cause, and overdosing harms the floc-forming bacteria and outlet quality.

Then remove the cause.

  1. Profile dissolved oxygen at several points and depths, at peak hours, and fix any shortfall.
  2. Check nutrients against the 100:5:1 guide and dose if short.
  3. Keep the equalisation tank aerobic.
  4. Fix fat removal upstream.
  5. Where bulking keeps returning, consider a selector ahead of the aeration tank, which favours floc formers over filaments.

Bulking sludge holds water, so a bulking plant wastes more and dewaters worse. Our guides on how to reduce sludge in an ETP and ETP sludge cover what that does to the disposal bill.

Where oxygen nanobubbles help with bulking

Only where low oxygen is the trigger. In lab reactors given the same air, nanobubble aeration produced more compact sludge with fewer filamentous bacteria than coarse-bubble aeration. [S1] Another lab study, on sequencing batch reactors, compared nanobubble aeration with fine-bubble aeration and found the nanobubble sludge was denser and quicker to settle. [S2] Both were lab scale, and a 2023 review notes most results are still at that scale. [S3]

A side-stream generator raises oxygen without draining the tank or adding blowers; our guide to fine bubble diffuser vs nanobubble generator explains how the two work together. It will not fix bulking caused by nutrient shortage or low F/M, and it does nothing for rising sludge or pin floc.

We have not yet published SVI data from our own plants. When we do, it will appear on this page. For the wider picture, see nanobubbles for ETP.

What to send us

  • SVI and MLSS for the last few weeks
  • Dissolved oxygen readings, with where and when they were taken
  • Inlet COD or BOD, and nitrogen and phosphorus if measured
  • Clarifier size and blanket depth
  • Microscope photos of the mixed liquor, if you have them

Sludge bulking: FAQ

What is a normal SVI?

Sludge with an SVI below about 100 mL/g generally settles well, and values above about 150 mL/g point to bulking. Watch the trend as well as the number: a steady rise over a week says more than one reading.

Does chlorine cure sludge bulking?

It can knock filaments back quickly when dosed carefully into the return sludge, but it does not remove the cause, and overdosing harms the floc-forming bacteria and outlet quality. Use it to protect the outlet while you fix the trigger.

Is foam on the aeration tank the same as bulking?

Not quite. Foam comes from filaments that gather at the surface, often encouraged by fats; bulking is poor settling in the clarifier. The two often appear together and share causes, so check SVI as well.

Sources (3)
  1. Yaparatne, S. et al. (2022). Effect of air nanobubbles on oxygen transfer, oxygen uptake, and diversity of aerobic microbial consortium in activated sludge reactors. Bioresource Technology 351, 127090. doi.org
  2. Ahmadi, Doroodmand and Nabi Bidhendi (2022). Efficient wastewater treatment via aeration through a novel nanobubble system in sequence batch reactors. Frontiers in Energy Research 10, 884353. doi.org
  3. Jia et al. (2023). Nanobubbles in water and wastewater treatment systems: Small bubbles making big difference. Water Research 245, 120613. doi.org

Sludge not settling?

Send your SVI, MLSS and dissolved oxygen readings for the last few weeks. We reply within one working day.

Not sure whether nanobubbles fit your ETP?

Send your flow sheet and recent lab results. An engineer will tell you which stage we would look at first, and whether a test is worth running.

Talk to an engineer